• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Linear Motion Tips

Covering Linear Motion Systems, Components and Linear Motion Resources

  • New
    • Editor’s blog
    • Industry news
    • Motion Casebook
    • Video
  • Applications
  • Slides + guides
    • Ball + roller guides
    • Track roller (cam + wheel) guides
    • Crossed-roller slides
    • Linear bearings
    • Plastic + composite guides
  • Drives
    • Ball + lead + roller screws
    • Belt + chain drives for linear
    • Rack + pinion sets
  • Actuators
    • Ball + leadscrew driven
    • Belt + chain driven
    • Linear motors
    • Mini + piezo + voice coil
    • Rack + pinion driven
    • Rigid-chain actuators
  • Encoders + sensors (linear) + I/O
  • Stages + gantries
  • Suppliers

When does open-loop stepper control still make sense?

April 7, 2021 By Danielle Collins Leave a Comment

Stepper motors are inherently open-loop devices, able to make precise moves without feedback regarding motor position. But one of the drawbacks of using stepper motors in some applications is that if steps are lost (or gained), the system has no way to detect this. The resulting discrepancy between the actual position of the motor and where it should be located according to the number of commanded steps can lead to errors in manufacturing or assembly, collisions with other parts of the machine, or even safety hazards for personnel.

To address the potential issues with lost (or gained) steps — and, in some cases, improve other aspects of motor performance, such as torque delivery and efficiency — several closed-loop stepper control methods have been developed. Sometimes referred to as servo steppers, these closed-loop control methods have been widely touted as an alternative to smaller-scale servo systems and a better option for many open-loop stepper applications.

However, despite the benefits of closed-loop control methods, traditional open-loop control continues to dominate stepper motor applications. Here, we look at some of the application requirements for which open-loop stepper control makes the most sense.

open-loop vs closed-loop control
Open- versus closed-loop control of stepper motors.
Image credit: Nanotec

Predictable, stable loads

In stepper motor applications, if the operating boundaries — as defined by the motor’s torque-speed curve — are exceeded, the motor can lose steps or stall. While a stalled motor can disrupt the manufacturing or assembly process, lost steps can be especially detrimental, since the open-loop control system has no way to detect that steps have been lost. This is why many stepper motors are over-sized for the application’s defined operating parameters — to give some measure of safety, or torque margin, in case of unforeseen operating conditions. But when the application is well-defined, with predictable loads that don’t undergo significant changes, a properly sized stepper motor can provide very accurate, reliable positioning under open-loop control.

High torque at low speeds

Stepper motors produce maximum torque when the motor is at standstill and continue to provide very high torque at speeds up to 1000 or 1200 rpm. Servo motors, on the other hand, often require a gearbox to multiply the torque and reduce the speed from the motor. But the addition of a gearbox reduces system stiffness by introducing backlash and compliance. Since stepper motors don’t require mechanical gearing to produce high torque at low speeds, they also have an advantage in overall system stiffness for these applications.

open-loop stepper
Stepper motors produce maximum torque at zero speed, and with open-loop control, they can hold a load at a precise location, since the motor doesn’t “hunt” for position.
Image credit: Galil

Holding a load in a fixed position

Because they produce full torque at standstill, stepper motors are able to hold a load in place, even against external forces. This is especially useful in processing applications, where a load is held stationary while some operation — such as assembly or machining — is performed, or while waiting for the next movement. Closed-loop systems can also hold loads, but because they constantly correct for any errors between the commanded and the actual position, the load is never truly at standstill, as the motor continuously “hunts” for its commanded position. Because there is no feedback loop to force position corrections, stepper motors with open-loop control are able to hold a load at a precise location without hunting.

open-loop stepper
Stepper motors with open-loop control can hold a load against an external force.
Image credit: Oriental Motor U.S.A. Corp

Need for speed (control)

The rotational speed of an open-loop stepper motor is determined by the frequency of pulses delivered to the motor, giving stepper motors very tight speed control. And the motor’s response to speed changes (changes in the frequency of supplied voltage) is practically instantaneous since there is no feedback loop to introduce processing delays.

Simple integration

Without the additional hardware required for feedback — particularly the sensor or encoder and related wiring — the up-front cost of an open-loop stepper motor system is inherently lower than that of a closed-loop stepper or servo system. Open-loop stepper control also provides cost savings due to its simple integration, with no need for parameterization and control loop tuning.


While closed-loop control methods can make stepper motors an attractive choice for applications previously reserved for servo systems, in many cases, the choice between closed- or open-loop stepper motor control still comes down to simplicity and cost.

You may also like:

  • stepper motor resonance
    What is stepper motor resonance and how can it be…

  • Stepper motor performance: Is it possible to get high torque…

  • When should you use microstepping control for stepper motors?
  • stator phases
    How does the number of stator phases affect stepper motor…

  • Stepper motors: Differences between permanent magnet, variable reluctance, and hybrid…

Filed Under: Controls for linear axes, FAQs + basics, Featured

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Primary Sidebar

DESIGN GUIDE LIBRARY

“motion
Subscribe Today

RSS Featured White Papers

  • Evaluating actuators for washdown in food & beverage applications
  • Identifying Best-Value Linear Motion Technologies
  • Introduction to accuracy and repeatability in linear motion systems

RSS Motion Control Tips

  • Bush and shaft assemblies feature 4-micron clearance
  • New gearboxes for electric motors in mobile machines
  • Leading motion-control and actuation options for robotics
  • Basics of wave and cycloidal gearing for robotics and servo designs
  • New micro servo-drive system for extra-low-voltage manufacturing applications

Footer

Linear Motion Tips

Design World Network

Design World Online
The Robot Report
Coupling Tips
Motion Control Tips
Bearing Tips
Fastener Engineering

Linear Motion Tips

Subscribe to our newsletter
Advertise with us
Contact us
About us

Follow us on TwitterAdd us on FacebookAdd us on LinkedInAdd us on YouTubeAdd us on Instagram

Copyright © 2022 · WTWH Media LLC and its licensors. All rights reserved.
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media.

Privacy Policy